Eagles mailbag: What number of NFL quarterbacks would you defend over Carson Wentz? – PhillyVoice.com

In our Eagles chat on Tuesday, there had been a form of questions that we might per chance well no longer ranking to in time or utterly different questions we did answer nonetheless might per chance well exhaust more coloration. And so, let’s enact a mailbag put up to answer to some of the overflow, as neatly as some recurrently asked questions on Twitter and by task of electronic mail.

Build a question to from Mike G: What number of quarterbacks within the NFL would you defend over Carson Wentz?

That relies upon. What number of would I defend, specifically in 2020? Or how many would I defend if we’re having a glimpse at it from a protracted-timeframe perspective, factoring in age, contract, and masses others.?

Staunch for 2020, I would defend the following quarterbacks over Wentz:

  1. Patrick Mahomes, Chiefs
  2. Russell Wilson, Seahawks
  3. Lamar Jackson, Ravens
  4. Aaron Rodgers, Packers
  5. Drew Brees, Saints
  6. Presumably Deshaun Watson, Texans

I’ve or no longer it is actually end between Wentz and Watson. Call that one a toss up. So he is either my sixth- or seventh-most efficient quarterback, elegant now, within the NFL.

If we’re speaking long-timeframe, that that you just can per chance traipse forward and defend Rodgers and Brees off of the above checklist. Nevertheless there are attention-grabbing debates between Wentz-Watson, and Wentz-Jackson.

  1. Wentz-Watson: Wentz already got paid, nonetheless he has a crew-friendly deal, relative to utterly different quarterbacks spherical the league, and upcoming quarterback affords tend to was inflated. I would fairly be locked into Wentz’s most original deal than need to grief about paying Watson as powerful as $40 million per 365 days.
  2. Wentz-Jackson: I enact wonder how long Jackson’s form of play might be sustainable. He’s likely essentially the most palatable player within the league, nonetheless he will not be any longer the greatest man, and his body is probably going to defend considerably more punishment than perchance any utterly different quarterback within the NFL. So that’s pertaining to. Nevertheless, so is Wentz’s ruin history. Jackson mild has two years left on his rookie deal, plus a fifth-365 days likelihood, so I would potentially traipse Jackson.

So from the long-timeframe perspective, I would have Wentz because the fourth-most appealing quarterback within the NFL, boring Mahomes, Russ, and Lamar.

Build a question to from deltaVee: The Eagles’ offensive roster
turnover is great low. That need to be an serve no longer no longer up to early on, no?

The Eagles have a major serve in 2020, in my
realizing, since the instructing workers (on the tip spots, anyway) is returning for
its fifth season, while each and each of the three groups within the NFC East have unusual head

I hadn’t belief about roster turnover into that equation, nonetheless
yes, while I deem the Eagles wished to enact more this offseason to support Carson
Wentz, the Eagles’ continuity on the offensive aspect of the ball, in theory,
ought to mild require less time getting encourage on the an analogous page. And needless to claim, cohesion
is advantageous on all sides of the ball, nonetheless it is done more slowly on

Build a question to from PhillyRob: Jimmy, now that the draft is
executed and FA is basically total, which strikes would the Birds no longer were in a scheme
to originate had they re-signed Malcolm Jenkins?

They didn’t need to re-signal him. He became already on the crew.
They slash him! Nevertheless to answer to your ask, obviously there’s nothing they did
this offseason that they couldn’t enact if they saved Jenkins. Presumably Mills stays at
CB, Avonte Maddox is the slot, and additionally they don’t signal Nickell Robey-Coleman? That’s
the alternate Universe I would envision if they had elegant saved Jenkins.

Build a question to from Josh: Has there been any discussion
about Fletcher Cox’s broad cap number this 365 days and next? I’ve his cap number
is top 10 within the league, and he beneath-performed final 365 days.

Dak Prescott, Russell Wilson, Jared Goff, Jimmy Garoppolo,
Philip Rivers, Tom Brady, Ben Roethlisberger, Drew Brees, Ryan Tannehill,
Khalil Mack, Von Miller, Aaron Donald, and DeForest Buckner all have better
wage cap numbers in 2020 than Cox, in step with OverTheCap. So he’s 14th, nonetheless
your point is neatly taken.

Cox had surgical blueprint final offseason, and didn’t actually
defend part at all in favour of the duration of practising camp or the preseason video games in 2019. I enact
instruct there’s motive to deem a fully wholesome Cox might be encourage to connect in
2020, specifically with a loaded DT rotation that will allow Jim Schwartz to be
more actually applicable about his usage, keeping him unique for the paunchy season.

Ought to you’re insinuating that Cox ought to mild defend a pay slash, why
would he? There’s zero menace of the crew releasing him, so there’s no incentive
for Cox to defend less. I enact deem that he is a prime candidate for a contract
restructure, by which they convert some of his wage into a signing bonus, and
stretch his cap numbers into future years.

Build a question to from Bird Gang: We hear that powerful of the rookie
class’s contributions in 2020 might be on particular groups. With the disappearance
of many returns as a result of recent rule modifications, hasn’t particular groups price been
considerably diminished?

Kickoff returns in affirm have diminished considerably,
so yes, guys who also play on particular groups are considerably less precious than
they had been, yelp, 10 years within the past.

Nonetheless, the Eagles didn’t draft Davion Taylor within the third
spherical, as an instance, attributable to he initiatives as an instantaneous particular groups
contributor. They took him attributable to they admire his athletic traits and additionally they deem
he can was a starter within the everyday protection. Because he can ranking down the
field rapid and originate tackles on particular groups, that’s a dinky bonus.

(As a aspect point, again, I enact accept as true with the purpose that
particular groups aren’t as essential as they as soon as had been, nonetheless it is price noting
that the Eagles potentially would have overwhelmed the Lions final 365 days with out the
Lions’ kick return TD.)

Build a question to from Cthulhu: If I am Jalen Hurts ought to mild I be
overjoyed or enraged I became drafted by the Eagles?

If I had been Hurts, I would have powerful fairly been drafted by a
crew that affords a clearer course to starting. I’d have most stylish to were taken
by any of the following groups: Steelers, Colts, Jaguars, Titans, Broncos,
Raiders, Bears, Lions, Falcons, Panthers, or Buccaneers.

Build a question to from Ross: Your diagnosis of TJ Edwards became
shined a light-weight on how solid he became in limited time final 365 days. It makes me feel
a small bit better about our linebackers. Any likelihood you are going to defend a more in-depth glimpse at
Gerry as neatly?

Thanks! I hadn’t planned on having a glimpse at Gerry, attributable to he
began quite a lot of the season, nonetheless he’s been a frequent attach a question to, so I’ll add him to
the checklist.

Build a question to from Frank Furter: Nathans or Oscar Meyer?

I’ll give the nod to Oscar Meyer, attributable to of their ziplock

Put together Jimmy & PhillyVoice on Twitter: @JimmyKempski | @thePhillyVoice

Love us on Facebook: PhillyVoice Sports activities

Add Jimmy’s RSS feed to your feed reader

Read Extra

Leave a comment

Stay up to date
Register now to get updates on promotions and coupons.

Shopping cart